A Comparison of Worst First Forestry and Diameter Limit Cutting: Long-term Yields and Valuations in Northwestern Pennsylvania Forests
Persistent URL
Author(s)
Hurst, Valerie Lynn Zablotny
Date Issued
2018
Abstract
Worst first (WF) forestry is a single-tree selection management approach that strategically removes undesirable species and cull trees to allow other desirable crop trees to reach financial maturity. Diameter limit cutting (DLC) is a common practice in northwestern Pennsylvania forests that removes trees above a certain diameter. Using a modeled 16 inch diameter limit cut and input from a local expert forester in worst first forestry, this study modeled cuts to three northwestern Pennsylvania mixed hardwood stands over a 40 year period. SILVAH 7.0 computer growth simulations modeled long term volume and value yields. This study treated diameter limit cutting and worst first forestry as mutually exclusive investments so as to compare revenues from harvests and net present value (NPV). The empirical results reveal that at 2, 4 and 6% discount rates WF generally outperforms DLC for NPV when all study plots are combined, but prior stand characteristics impact individual stand response. Worst first registered greater total harvest revenues in two of the three stands and greater residual stand volume and value.
Major
Environmental Studies
Economics
Honors
Economics, 2018
Environmental Science / Studies, 2018
First Reader(s)
Bowden, Richard D.
Nonnenmacher, Tomas W.
Department
Environmental Science / Studies
Economics
Type of Publication
Dataset
Image
Senior Project Paper
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
Hurst_S2018_FINALCOMP.pdf
Description
Senior Composition
Size
1.34 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (etag)
2c38ecb10e4343b39c0ffd1127d9943a